Moselio Schaechter


  • The purpose of this blog is to share my appreciation for the width and depth of the microbial activities on this planet. I will emphasize the unusual and the unexpected phenomena for which I have a special fascination... (more)

    For the memoirs of my first 21 years of life, click here.

Associate Bloggers



  • (Click photo for more information.)

Bloggers Emeriti


  • (Click photo for more information.)

Meetings & Sponsors



« Talmudic Question #54 | Main | Fiddling with Fungi: And the Winner Is… »

October 19, 2009

Small Friends of Fungi

This article first appeared in the splendid Cornell Mushroom Blog. Reading it, we were jolted into realizing that we had a distorted view of the living world, no less. Like most people, we believed that in natural habitats, some animals eat plants, those animals are eaten by predators, and that's about it. We thank Bob Mesibov for setting us straight. We are delighted to share his insights with you by reproducing his article here, with permission from him and from Kathie Hodge, editor and blogificator of the Cornell Mushroom Blog.

by Bob Mesibov

Narceus

The millipede Narceus americanus photographed by
Kent Loeffler, copyright Cornell University. You can
find this borescopic image among the many in the
book Beneath Notice: Adventures with a Borescope
by Kent Loeffler, with "Fungal Outbursts" by Kathie
Hodges.

If you studied the traditional sort of biology, you're probably carrying around an unfortunate prejudice.

You see terrestrial habitats as a simplified nutrients-and-energy pyramid. At the bottom are green plants, feeding on sunlight, carbon dioxide and soil water and minerals. Next layer up on the pyramid is the herbivore mob: leaf and stem eaters, sapsuckers, root nibblers, seed and fruit gobblers. Above these green feeders are a couple of layers of predators. And that about sums up the world, right?

Wrong. That's only part of the world, and a small, very specialised part of it, too.

To begin with, most animals can't eat green food. Herbivores are dietary specialists among the insects, mollusks, birds and mammals. Your average green leaf or stem doesn't show much herbivore damage, and for good reason. It's mainly water boxed in by cellulose and other structural carbohydrates, which are impossible or extremely hard for animals to digest. Other nutrients are present, but at low concentrations. You need to eat a great mass of indigestible green stuff to get a decent return of elements like nitrogen, phosphorus, potassium and calcium. As for animals eating wood, which makes up most of the biomass in a forest – well, there are termites, and…um…termites…

The truth is that in the real world outside the biology classroom, only a tiny proportion of terrestrial primary production goes through the stomachs of the few evolutionary lineages brave enough to tackle what green plants produce. In any terrestrial habitat, the great bulk of primary production just does not get eaten. It sits, instead, at the bottom of a very different food pyramid. I call it the Dead Plants Society (DPS), as opposed to the Green Feeders Guild (GFG).

In the absence of fire, all that uneaten primary production is first attacked by fungi and bacteria. By 'attacked' I mean 'converted from low-nutrient indigestibles to concentrated yummies', i.e. fungal and bacterial bodies. Stacked on top of this microbial layer in the pyramid are microbivorous layers of nematodes, mites, springtails, earthworms, millipedes and other soil animals. On top of those are predators – but picture 'centipede', not 'eagle'.

The GFG and DPS animal communities differ in many ways. To begin with, in any given habitat the GFG has very high species diversity (think of plant-eating insects) but low higher-taxon diversity, while the DPS has great higher-taxon diversity (lots of strange sorts of animals), but low species diversity. Next, GFG herbivores tend to specialise on particular plants, while DPS microbivores will eat anything that's rotting nicely. There are also a lot of winged GFG members ('gotta find that particular plant I like…'), whereas almost no DPS members have wings, at least in their younger, feeding stages. There's an architectural difference, too. The GFG extends well up in the air, to ca. 100 m in some tall forests, while the DPS is largely confined to the ground.

Then there's the matter of heritage. The earliest DPS fossils are of mites, springtails and millipedes, and they're more than 400 million years old, from a time when terrestrial vegetation was mainly mossy and ground-hugging. The first solid evidence for green feeding (early insects with spores in their guts) appears much later in the fossil record, from coal swamp times. The DPS is vastly older than the GFG, and when you handle richly organic soil you're holding animal communities which are spectacularly ancient and robust. You can almost imagine a springtail thinking: 'Seen the dinosaurs come and go, mammals are nearly done. Wonder what great lumbering dopes we'll see in the next 100 million years? Yum, love these hyphae with yeast sprinkles!'

Bob




Dr. Robert Mesibov is a taxonomist from down under who studies seriously fungophilic animals: millipedes. Check out his other many-legged doings via his website. A previous article on the Dead Plants Society is available here.

Comments

is a large North American millipede. It inhabits the eastern seaboard of the United States through southeastern Canada and west to central Texas. It is one of the largest North American millipede species, reaching a length of four inches. When threatened, they sometimes curl up or release a noxious liquid that contains large amounts of benzoquinones which can cause dermatological burns. This fluid may irritate eyes or skin. Many other millipedes secrete hydrogen cyanide, and while there have also been claims that N. americanus releases hydrogen cyanide, this is not true.

Fascinating reworking of the common paradigm, but there is also the consumption of carnivores and other animals by mites, fungii, and other microbiota. They are consuming me as I write, which makes most of the vegetarian arguments, based on that inaccurate pyramid irrelevant.

Interesting stuff. Is this as true in grasslands as it is in the forest? It seems like tons of ruminants manage to make the economics of grass cellulose work for them. There are also folivores in the proper sense, which eat trees, but they seem to be fewer in biomass and diversity if my nonscientific impressions are right. Are they more predation-limited for some reason than grazers? Do grasses bleed more energy to the Green Feeders than trees do? Are any herbivores limited malthusianly (by parasites and intraspecific competition & violence)? Or is there always an apex predator that can trim them down? (Lions of course used to exist in the New World, until quite recently.)

One theory, which I just made up after reading wikipedia[folivores], is based on the observation that flying animals are rarely folivores because the amount of cellulose digesta they'd need to hold is so heavy. It says that folivorous bats chew leaves and soon eject the recalcitrant material such as cellulose, which tallies with this. My suggestion is that the same thing may apply more weakly to climbers, so there are less folivores than grazers. Cows are much freer than monkeys to carry around many kg of digesta, as well as the more massive digestive tract needed to deal with that stuff.

This post of John Dennehy's might be relevant:
http://evilutionarybiologist.blogspot.com/2008/06/this-weeks-citation-classic-world-is.html

Verify your Comment

Previewing your Comment

This is only a preview. Your comment has not yet been posted.

Working...
Your comment could not be posted. Error type:
Your comment has been saved. Comments are moderated and will not appear until approved by the author. Post another comment

The letters and numbers you entered did not match the image. Please try again.

As a final step before posting your comment, enter the letters and numbers you see in the image below. This prevents automated programs from posting comments.

Having trouble reading this image? View an alternate.

Working...

Post a comment

Comments are moderated, and will not appear until the author has approved them.

Teachers' Corner

Podcast

How to Interact with This Blog

  • We welcome readers to answer queries and comment on our musings. To leave a comment or view others, remarks, click the "Comments" link in red following each blog post. We also occasionally publish guest blog posts from microbiologists, students, and others with a relevant story to share. If you are interested in authoring an article, please email us at elios179 at gmail dot com.

Subscribe via email

Translate




Search




MicrobeWorld News

Membership